The chosen one trope is one of my favorites, and since the cover for my book, Rebel, Brave and Brutal, is being revealed today, and since my main character falls into this category, I think it’s the perfect time to discuss why I love it so much.
Real quick: The cover reveal for Rebel, Brave and Brutal is live! Tap this link to see the cover, read the summary, and enter to win an advance copy!
Before we talk about the chosen one stories, let’s talk about what a trope is, and why they’re useful to both readers and writers.
A trope is something of a cliché, a device that is used so often within a genre it’s become commonplace or expected. Unsurprising, to say the least.
Some common tropes in young adult literature:
-the love triangle
-soft-hearted tough guy
-enemies to lovers
-one bed, two characters
-the absent parents
-the orphan hero
-fake boyfriend/girlfriend
-a town too small for the protagonist’s big dreams
-opposites attract
-ugly duckling turns into a swan
-the dependable sidekick
-the reluctant hero
I bet these concepts/character types sound a bit familiar to you!
Even if you don’t read teen fiction, it’s easy to see many of the most popular YA tropes included in books of all genres, for all age groups. And there’s a good reason for that: Authors depend on tropes because they appeal to a wide array of readers. In short, tropes work. And they work because when they’re done well, they illustrate or draw on a universal truth or desire.
A large percentage of readers can either identify with or sympathize with many of the same situations. We have much in common, and that is clearly seen when we read fiction book summaries. In fact, the next time you’re at the bookstore, work your way down an aisle picking up books and reading the back or inside flap. My guess is you’ll be able to pick out a trope or two that repeats itself again and again.
While tropes can take a lot of heat for contributing to unoriginal storytelling, the trick isn’t to avoid tropes altogether, but to put your own spin on them. And therein lies the magic. Take what readers want and can identify with, and breath new life into it or show it from a different angle. Most of the time, trying too hard to be unique can be stumbling block. So, instead of trying to be the most original storyteller in the world, shoot for authentic. That’s even better.
But I digress!
The chosen one! That’s why we’re here today, to discuss just why it’s among my favorite tropes. I bet you can think of a few books that lean into the idea of a chosen one, a savior, the only one who can save humanity. A few off the top of my head:
-Harry Potter from . . . well, you know.
-Neo from the Matrix
-Frodo from the Lord of the Rings
-Alina Starkov from Shadow and Bone
-Katniss Everdeen from Hunger Games
and of course
-Sylvi Quine from Winter, White and Wicked
What I love about these six characters specifically is that they all ascended to chosen one status by different means. Harry Potter and Neo ended up there because of a prophecy. Frodo inherited a ring and a task he would have willingly given away (also the reluctant hero). Alina Starkov was born with a singular power. Katniss volunteered to fight to protect her sister, and this selfless act endeared her to a nation. And then, Sylvi Quine, the hero from Winter, White and Wicked, was born into responsibilities she knew nothing about.
The original chosen one, of course, is Jesus Christ. The God-man come to die for the world. This pattern is evident in so many chosen one stories, but while a great sacrifice is often demanded of fictional chosen ones, it isn’t always their life they forfeit. And it goes without saying, our heroes are rarely sinless.
Therein lies the greatest advice I could ever give for using tropes in your writing. They are to be leaned into, not mimicked. Tropes give us a heading, not a map. How you get to your destination is entirely up to you, and the journey is what will resonate with your readers.
Take me, for example. The reason I’m so drawn to chosen one stories isn’t because one character gets to be more special and that somehow reflects reality. No, not at all. The reason I’m drawn to chosen one stories is because in our own ways, and in our own spheres of influence, we are often thrust into the hero’s role whether we like it or not. And if we don’t find ourselves pushed into such a job, we can certainly choose to be chosen.
Every one of us can stand for the downtrodden. We can use the power we’re given to fight for those who can’t fight for themselves. We each have gifts, and when they’re called into service, we get to decide whether or not to use them.
I love watching characters choose bravery over fear, others over themselves, right over comfortable. I love it because it’s real. Because in my life, and in those around me, it’s a daily choice.
So, yes. I love chosen one stories. But it’s the journey that captivates me. The falling and the getting back up. The pushing forward because it matters. The fighting because there are things worth fighting for. Every bit of that resonates with me because we fall, we push, and we fight. The humanity inside these often superhuman characters is what I love. It inspires me.
And today, I wonder if there are tropes that inspire you.
Tell me, do you have a favorite trope? Are there tropes you’re tired of seeing? Or maybe you love how an author has given an old trope a fresh feel? I’d love to hear about it!
Shannon Dittemore is an author and speaker. Her books include the Angel Eyes trilogy, a supernatural foray into the realm of angels and demons, as well as the fantastical adventure novel Winter, White and Wicked. Its sequel, Rebel, Brave and Brutal is due out January 10, 2023.
Shannon’s stories feature strong female leads grappling with fear and faith as they venture into the wilds of the unknown. She’s often wondered if she’s writing her own quest for bravery again and again.
It’s a choice she values highly. Bravery. And she’s never more inspired than when young people ball up their fist and punch fear in the face.
To that end, Shannon takes great joy in working with young writers, both in person and online at Go Teen Writers, an instructional blog recognized by Writer’s Digest four years running as a “101 Best Websites for Writers” selection.
For more about Shannon and her books, please visit her website, Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest.
Cover Reveal day!!! That is sooo exciting!!!!! I’m excited to see it, but unfortunately I can’t join Live because of persnickety Wifi. ?
Honestly, I cannot stand the old “love triangle”. Two guys fighting over the same girl whilst the poor girl stands in a fog… it irks me a little. (okay, more than a little…)
But I DO love the mean-looking-guy-who’s-really-a-teddy-bear. It’s always so cute.
My WIP, in a way, takes a really unique spin on the enemies to lovers trope, or maybe more the sweet-girl-softens-the-grumpy-misanthrope trope.
Just wondering– do you have any tips on how to write a character where the reader is unsure of what they are?? In my WIP, I want to make the reader wonder whether my male lead is a werewolf or not, but I am struggling!
Potential solutions to your “make them wonder if he’s a werewolf” predicament: maybe give the werewolves in your story some typical werewolf traits while disregarding others. You foreshadow that he is a werewolf because of he displays signs X, Y, and Z, but there’s just one thing that doesn’t add up that makes you question if he actually is. For example: maybe he always looks beat up and tired after a full moon, but he can touch silver without any adverse effects, so your reader is left to wonder “Is he human, or is the silver thing just a myth?”
(Not sure if that would work in the context of the rest of your WIP. Just a suggestion.)
That’s helpful, thank you! Incorporating that in, and balancing it with the romance element of my story, (it’s kinda been just mentioned in passing, like as a passive subplot, when I want to make it more active.) has been a bit tangly. But your tip actually gives me a few ideas on how to make those plots work together.
I actually had an idea for a book that kind of takes cliches and flips them on their heads. Like, the wise old wizard starts cracking jokes and making witty, ironic remarks, the sidekick strikes out on his own so no one else gets hurt and gives all the bad guys second chances, the chosen one is mostly useless but insanely powerful when he decides to help out, etc. Or maybe, to make things more confusing, the hero gets a pet dragon and starts wearing black and cackling evilly, and the villain becomes a mentor to the sidekick…. Ah, fun times.
I love the soft-hearted tough guy and the dependable sidekick tropes. I also like to take cliches or tropes and make them somewhat different, like the dependable sidekick who is actually a traitor, or the villain who loves to snuggle with his orange tabby kitten.
I like your story idea. It sounds great.
Thanks!
I would love to read of a supposed wise old wizard who can’t stop making jokes! I’m just imagining how confused the protagonist would be!
Oooh, I love the cover (and the title) of Rebel, Brave and Brutal. It looks so amazing!
I do have to admit, I love the chosen one trope too, probably because of my obsession with the Harry Potter books. It wasn’t my original plan, but I feel like my WIP may be moving in that direction. The dependable sidekick is another one that I love to see in use, especially when they also act as the comic relief.
I loved reading this! I’ve been so worried about exploiting too many tropes in my writing and how I should be unique, but your “Most of the time, trying too hard to be unique can be a stumbling block” was really encouraging that I don’t need to stress so much over particular plot points that might fall into trope territory.
One trope that I am a HUGE sucker for is the redemption arc. The characters who lost their way and turned to the dark side, then found their way again, and now must make a sacrifice to get back on the light side. (E.g, Prince Zuko from Avatar: the Last Airbender.) I like the moral ambiguity, since life is never clear, and the lengths to which the character must go in order to find redemption. It just gives me chills, every time!
Congratulations on a great cover!
Your article fits in nicely with a tool that I’ve been using lately: Jennifer Lynne Barnes’s Id List. Once I started making my own Id List (tropes, images, anything that resonates with you) and putting these elements in my work, I rediscovered the joy that I had when I was a kid writing stories without any worry of being derivative. And you are so right–the key is to put your own spin on something that is universal.