How Do You Know When Your Book Is Done?

I get this question a lot when I have the privilege of talking to young writers at writing conferences or over email. I hate that I can’t provide a, “If you’ve done A, B, and C, then your book is ready!” kind of answer.

Similar to how you “knew” that was the right name for your main character, or the best last line for your book, “knowing” that your book is done is more of a feel. This is a piece of the process that’s more intuitive than mathematical.

And sometimes my gut is more like, “I think my book is maybe done…?” rather than, “I’m SO ready! Let’s do this!”

When you’re a new writer, and you don’t have a process yet, it’s hard to follow the advice of “trust the process.” Some writers are three draft writers and others are twelve; Until you’ve written and edited a few manuscripts, how can you know and trust what you’re doing?

Every writer’s process is a bit different, but generally speaking your book needs to go through several rounds of edits, several rounds of feedback, and several rounds of copy editing before it reads like a real book.

If you have been writing stories for a few years or less, you are learning, growing, and changing crazy fast. Especially if you are a teen writer. If it takes you six months to write a first draft, you are likely a vastly different writer by the end of that process than you were at the beginning.

Seeing this kind of rapid growth is wonderful, but it’s also a challenge when you’re editing. Regarding their first novels, I frequently hear young writers say things like, “I may as well just scrap the whole beginning and rewrite it!”

And I understand, because I’ve been that writer!

I know we’re an impatient people, and nobody likes to hear “give it time” as advice, but I strongly believe in its value to the creative process. That’s why with every book, I give myself at least six weeks between the first draft and the second. I need that distance to be able to see the book clearly.

There’s nothing wrong with putting your completed book aside for a month or two, and then reevaluating it’s doneness. (Yeah, I know. Not a word.)

You know when I knew that I had become a good enough writer to be published? When an agent said to me, “You have a lovely writing voice!”

I thought, “I do? Yay, I’m finally here!”

Before she said that to me, I had no idea I had finally developed a writing voice. I just kept doing my best work, and then sending it out to agents and editors to see what they thought.

I know that’s a scary way to find out if your book is good enough to catch a professional’s eye. I wish you could just upload your Word Doc to a program and have it give you a red light or green light, but that’s not a thing yet. (Surely someone is working on it…)

But I can’t find a way around it: The only way to really know that your book is done and that you’re ready is to have not-family, not-friend people read it and give you their opinion.

This doesn’t mean that if one editor at one conference doesn’t like it, you should scrap the book and rewrite it. Again, this goes back to point number one, that deciding your book is done is largely a gut thing. We’ll talk more about receiving and incorporating feedback in the coming weeks as we transition into talking about publishing.

One last note: I picked the word “done” for this article because I heard a quote (I cannot figure out who said it, so if someone knows, please help me out) that “No book is ever finished, it’s just done.”

I’ve found that to be true in my own books, that I could nitpick them forever, and I imagine you’ll find it to be true for your stories as well.