Hi, writers! I’m home again, but just barely, so one more post from the archives.
When teen writers ask me about being published, one of the most common questions I get is about the idea of needing to pick one genre. They’ll say something like, “Is it true that editors only want you to publish in one genre? I like to write lots of different things—what should I do?”
I’ve also had writers tell me that they’ve chosen to self-publish because they don’t want to have to pick a genre, and this way they can write whatever they want. I always internally cringe a bit at this one. Not because I don’t understand this position; as an artist, I can totally relate to wanting to write whatever I want, whenever I feel like it.
The reason I cringe is that this outlook—I’m going to self-publish because I want to write whatever I want—ignores the “Why?” behind the advice of picking one genre, which is to satisfy readers.
Think about your favorite writer. Let’s say it’s Maggie Stiefvater, who mostly writes paranormal YA. What if you’ve just finished the Raven Cycle series, and you’ve spent months obsessing about the wonderfully strange world of Henrietta, and you’re waiting for Maggie to announce her next book.
And what if her next book is a contemporary romance novel about a single mom who learns she’s dying of cancer on the same day that she meets Mr. Right.
Now, that’s not a bad story idea. Maybe you like contemporary romances. Maybe if it was another author, you would see that description and think, “That could be good.” But after being immersed in a series where trees speak Latin and a boy can bring objects back from his dreams … you’d be disappointed, right? Because you have certain expectations about what reading a Maggie Stiefvater book will be like.
When industry professionals give you the advice of picking a genre, that is why. Because they know the value of protecting the reader’s experience and expectations.
Yeah, it matters financially (people tend to only keep buying books from authors they continue to like) but if you care about your readers, like most authors do, it matters in that sense too.
So whether you’re seeking traditional or indie publishing, this is an issue worth examining.
But I like to write lots of different types of books! What do I do?
If you are a young writer or a hobby writer, you just keep writing lots of different types of books. Don’t feel pressured to pick. If you want to write a medieval fantasy, followed by a 1940s murder mystery, and then a novel in verse, go for it.
The more you write, the more you’re going to learn about what kinds of stories you like to tell. You’ll start to notice patterns and themes, and even if you still like to write eclectic stories, you’ll start to figure out what links them all.
And even if you do all this, and you mostly write one genre, you might still find you have a wild hair of an idea that you’re just dying to write. You still can. Not everything you write has to be published. But if you do decide you want to publish that book…
How can I break this rule?
Lots of writers do. You can probably even name a few. Here are some ideas for how to get away with it:
Be “close enough”: Roseanna White writes Biblical fiction and also historical romance. Even though they’re different genres, she writes them under the same name. The readers for these are close enough that it’s fine. Same goes for Jill Williamson and her various speculative fiction novels.
Make it gradual: While it wouldn’t be a very smart audience-building move to write a historical mystery, and then follow it up with a contemporary romance, you can gradually make your way there. For example, after the historical mystery, you could follow it up with a historical romance with elements of mystery. And then it could be a dual generation story where you’re dealing with a contemporary setting and a historical setting.
With each new book, you can tweak the genre just a bit.
If you want to explore that idea more, this season of Writing Excuses has focused on something they call “Elemental Genre” and it can really help you dig into layering genres.
Use a pen name: Or maybe you have two or more genres you want to write in that draw different audiences. Maybe you like writing historical fantasy for teens, but you also like the futuristic sci-fi for adults too. If you have two distinct author brands that you’re wanting to pursue, that’s when a pen name can be a good idea.
Do your story ideas tend to fall into one genre, or are they varied?
Thanks for this post, Stephanie! I hope that your vacation went splendidly. I write a lot of historical fiction, epic fantasy/fantasy and dystopian. So, in short, my stories have never really fallen into the same genre. 🙂
Vacation went great, thank you!
And interesting that you like all of the “other worlds” genres 🙂
That is interesting! I didn’t think about how I like all of the “other worlds” genres before! It may have something to do with the fact that I have an overactive imagination and have always wanted a grand adventure, like the ones written about in books. 🙂
You must have read my mind, because I was literally thinking about this last night!
Most of my ideas fall within the realms of fantasy and paranormal fiction. I feel like those two genres are similar enough to allow me to specialize in both. A sort of “otherworldly” vibe will be at the core of my writing persona. However, I also have a few realistic-contemporary ideas that I’d love to publish some day. These tips will be great for when that day comes. Thanks! 🙂
I write mainly fantasy and contemporary. Most of my contemporary ideas I’d say are sort of similar in general ‘feeling’ and my fantasy ideas mostly revolve around the same world. My contemporary ideas feel more unique and publishable to me than my fantasy ideas, but I love all of them.
I do have some contemporary fantasy ideas too, so I could maybe use those for genre transition if I ever publish.
And I read your mind three weeks ago when I scheduled this post 😉
Yes, your primary genres align, fortunately! Plenty of time to figure out what to do with the realistic contemporaries down the road.
Oops I didn’t mean to put that as a reply
I’ve accidentally done that before too!
It’s so hard when you love multiple genres…
My genre is most definitely Biblical fiction. My current WIP is a novel about the apostle Paul, who is my favorite Biblical figure. I’m having a lot of fun with it!
Paul is fascinating. I adore Biblical fiction!
Ooh, yes! The world needs more Biblical fiction!
Oh that sounds like it would be super fun to write!
Thank you for this post and things to think about! I love to write anything dystopian or fantasy, other worlds with magic or advanced technology always intrigue me!
Which is all close enough to the same genre that you’ll probably be fine!
I write mostly dystopian, though I have a few outliers on my list of ideas. Never before have I thought about why authors might want to stick to a genre. So interesting, and it makes a lot of sense! Thank you for sharing!
Great advice! I heard recently ( I think on the Gatecrashers podcast, but not 100% sure) that when you choose a genre you should be prepared to write 5-10 books in it before switching.
Ugh, pushed send too fast.
I like chick lit but I know it’s not really a thing right now. I’ve been taking time to learn about different genres lately and how we can make them our own. Romance has surprised me, there’s more to it than I thought.
What about steampunk and paranormal? I haven’t found a lot of info on them. Are they similar?
I would argue that chick lit still exists, but we call it romantic comedy now, even in literature.
Paranormal and steampunk are both in the speculative genre and could overlap depending on how you write them.
Thank you for this great advice! I find that I prefer writing mostly medieval fantasy and early 20th century historical fiction.